Air Handling Units (AHUs) vs. Fan Coil Units (FCUs)

In HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) systems, Air Handling Units (AHUs) and Fan Coil Units (FCUs) are crucial components that play distinct roles in managing indoor air quality, temperature, humidity and comfort. Understanding the differences between these two units is essential for mechanical engineers involved in the design, installation, and maintenance of HVAC systems. This article provides a detailed comparison of AHUs and FCUs, focusing on their design, function, applications, and integration within HVAC systems.

Need More Information on HVAC Systems?

• A Quick Introduction to Air Handling Units
• How to Boost Your HVAC Efficiency and Decrease Costs

Overview of Air Handling Units (AHUs)

1.1 Function and Components

An Air Handling Unit (AHU) is a large, (typically 2000-100,000cfm) complex piece of equipment designed to regulate and circulate air within a building. It is typically part of a central HVAC system and is used to handle large volumes of air across multiple zones or an entire building. AHUs can be configured in various ways to include components such as:

• Blowers/Fans: These are responsible for moving air through the unit and into the building's ductwork. They ensure that air circulates effectively throughout the designated spaces.
• Heating/Cooling Coils: These coils condition the air by either heating or cooling it, depending on the requirements of the building. The coils use electric heating coils, chilled water, hot water, or refrigerants to achieve the desired air temperature.
• Filters: AHUs often contain multiple stages of filtration to remove particulates, dust, and other contaminants from the air. Usual filtration for commercial buildings uses MERV-13 grade filters.  High-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters may be used for environments with very stringent air quality requirements.
• Humidifiers/Dehumidifiers: Depending on the application, AHUs can include components to add or remove moisture from the air, maintaining optimal humidity levels.
• Mixing Chambers: These allow the mixing of return air from the building with fresh outdoor air.
• Dampers: Dampers control the flow of air into and out of the unit, helping to manage air pressure and ventilation rates.

1.2 Applications and Performance

AHUs are typically used in large commercial or industrial buildings, such as office towers, hospitals, shopping malls, and manufacturing facilities. Their ability to handle large volumes of air and integrate with other HVAC components makes them ideal for centralized air management.

AHUs can also be designed to serve specific needs, such as cleanrooms in pharmaceutical manufacturing or data centers where precise temperature and humidity control are critical. The size and complexity of AHUs mean they often require a dedicated mechanical room or are installed on rooftops to save rentable space within the building.

1.3 System Integration

AHUs are integrated into a building's central HVAC system, working in conjunction with chillers, boilers, cooling towers, and ductwork to distribute conditioned air throughout the facility. Their operation is controlled by a Building Management System (BMS), which allows for precise control of temperature, humidity, air quality, and energy consumption.

Questions about Trench Heaters?

• How to Install Trench Heaters
• Maximizing Efficiency From the Ground Up

Overview of Fan Coil Units (FCUs)

2.1 Function and Components

A Fan Coil Unit (FCU) is a simpler, smaller compact HVAC device designed to provide localized heating or cooling within specific rooms or small areas of a building. Unlike AHUs, FCUs do not typically handle outside air and are primarily used to control the temperature in individual spaces. Key components of an FCU include:

• Fan: The fan in an FCU circulates air over the heating or cooling coil, distributing the conditioned air into the room.
• Heating/Cooling Coil: The coil in an FCU may be an electric heating coil or the coil is connected to a central system that supplies either, hot water, chilled water, or refrigerant. The coil then heats or cools the air as it passes over the coil.
• Filter: FCUs contain filters to remove dust and particulates from the air, though these filters are generally less sophisticated than those in AHUs.
• Thermostat: Each FCU typically has a thermostat that allows users to set the desired temperature for the room or area it serves.

2.2 Applications and Performance

FCUs are commonly used in smaller buildings or individual spaces within larger buildings, such as hotel rooms, apartments, offices, and retail spaces. Their ability to provide localized temperature control makes them ideal for environments where occupants have varying comfort preferences.

FCUs are often used in buildings where central air distribution is not feasible or cost-effective. For example, in retrofitting older buildings without existing ductwork, FCUs can be a practical solution for adding air conditioning or supplemental heating. The routing of small pipes is easier than routing large ducts.

2.3 System Integration

Unlike AHUs, FCUs operate independently within their designated areas. They are connected to a central heating and cooling system through pipes that supply hot or cold water. Because FCUs do not handle ventilation or fresh air intake, they are often used in conjunction with other systems that provide these functions, such as AHUs or dedicated ventilation units.

FCUs offer flexibility in HVAC design because they allow for decentralized control. Each unit can be individually controlled, providing occupants with the ability to adjust the temperature to their liking without affecting other areas of the building.

Interested in UFAD?

• What Every Architect Needs to Know about UFAD
• What is a UFAD System?
  

Key Differences Between AHUs and FCUs

3.1 Scale and Capacity

One of the most significant differences between AHUs and FCUs is the scale at which they operate. AHUs are designed for large-scale air handling, capable of conditioning and distributing air across multiple zones or an entire building. In contrast, FCUs are smaller units intended for localized temperature control in individual rooms or small areas.

3.2 Air Handling and Ventilation

AHUs are responsible for not only heating and cooling but also for managing ventilation, building pressure and air quality. They can handle large volumes of outside air, which is crucial for maintaining indoor air quality in commercial and industrial settings. FCUs, on the other hand, do not typically handle outside air and are focused solely on temperature control. This makes AHUs essential for buildings that require ventilation and fresh air intake, while FCUs are more suited for spaces where only localized temperature control is needed.

3.3 Installation and Maintenance

AHUs are typically larger, more complex systems that require dedicated space for installation, such as mechanical rooms or rooftops. Their maintenance involves regular checks of components like filters, coils, fans, and control systems, often requiring specialized knowledge and equipment. FCUs are smaller, simpler units that are easier to install and maintain. They are often installed in ceilings, walls, or floors, and their maintenance primarily involves cleaning or replacing filters and checking the operation of fans and coils.

3.4 Energy Efficiency and Control

AHUs, being part of a central HVAC system, can be controlled by a Building Management System (BMS), allowing for centralized control and monitoring of energy use. This can lead to more efficient operation, especially in large buildings. FCUs, with their localized control, offer flexibility in energy use but may not be as efficient in large-scale applications where centralized control would be more effective.

Advantages of Raised Access Floor

• Advantages of Raised Access Floors: 4 Signs That You’re Missing the Mark
• How a Raised Access Floor Can Attract More Tenants to a Rental Property

Conclusion

In summary, Air Handling Units (AHUs) and Fan Coil Units (FCUs) serve different purposes within HVAC systems and are suitable for different types of applications. AHUs are designed for large-scale air handling and ventilation, making them ideal for commercial and industrial buildings. They offer comprehensive control over air quality, temperature, and humidity but require significant space and maintenance.

FCUs, on the other hand, are more compact units that provide localized temperature control. They are easier to install and maintain, making them suitable for smaller buildings or individual spaces within larger buildings. However, their limited ability to handle ventilation and outside air makes them less suitable for environments where air quality is a primary concern.

For mechanical engineers, understanding these differences is crucial for selecting the appropriate equipment for specific building requirements. Whether designing a new HVAC system or retrofitting an existing one, the choice between AHUs and FCUs will depend on factors such as the size of the building, the need for centralized vs. localized control, and the importance of air quality and ventilation.

AirFixture helps architects and engineers deliver building projects within budget and timelines by designing, delivering, and installing UFAD HVAC systems. See our FREE guide about UFAD to understand how to provide an HVAC system that lowers building OPEX.

This blog was written by Chat GPT and edited by AirFixture, LLC. for clarity.